1. Home
  2. GST
  3. Transitional special cases
GST guide · transition

Transitional provisions for special cases under GST: Sections 141 and 142

Some transactions in 2017 started under the old tax laws and finished under GST: goods out for job work, goods returned by customers, price revisions, goods sent on approval and long-running contracts. Sections 141 and 142 of the CGST Act set the rules for each. Here they are in plain words.

  • Updated
  • 4 min read
  • Milaan ERP GST team

Key points

  • Job work: goods sent before GST could come back without tax within six months (extendable by two).
  • Goods returned: duty-paid goods returned within six months could get a refund under the old law.
  • Price revisions: supplementary invoices or credit notes had to be issued within 30 days.
  • Goods on approval: goods sent before GST and returned within six months were not taxed.
  • The 2017 transition windows are closed. This guide is for understanding old records, assessments and disputes, and for lessons that still apply when tax rules change.

Job work (Section 141)

Manufacturers often send inputs, semi-finished goods or finished goods to job workers. If goods were sent under the old law before 1 July 2017 and returned on or after that date, no tax was payable on their return if they came back within six months. The period could be extended by up to two months for good reason. If the goods didn’t come back in time, credit could be recovered. Both the sender and job worker had to declare the goods held.

Goods returned by customers (Section 142(1))

If goods sold up to six months before GST, with duty or tax paid, were returned after 1 July 2017 within six months of the appointed day, the seller could claim a refund of the old duty, provided the goods could be identified. If the customer was registered under GST, the return was treated as a supply by them.

Price revisions (Section 142(2))

If a contract made before GST was revised after 1 July 2017, the seller had to issue a supplementary invoice or debit note (for an increase) or a credit note (for a reduction) within 30 days of the revision. These were treated as issued under GST.

Pending refunds and appeals (Section 142(3)–(8))

  • Refund claims filed before or after GST for amounts under the old law were decided under the old law and paid in cash.
  • Appeals, revisions and reviews about the old law continued under that law, with any amount found due recovered or refunded accordingly.
  • Assessments of the old law periods continued under the old law.

Long-term contracts (Section 142(10))

Goods or services supplied on or after 1 July 2017 under contracts signed earlier were taxed under GST. For works contracts and other long-running agreements, this meant splitting supplies by date and making sure tax was not paid twice on the same value.

Tax paid in advance under the old law (Section 142(11))

Where VAT or service tax had already been paid on an advance or part of a supply under the old law, that tax could be taken as credit to avoid double taxation when the same supply became taxable under GST.

Goods sent on approval (Section 142(12))

Goods sent on approval up to six months before GST and returned within six months of the appointed day were not taxed. If they were not returned in time, the person who had them had to pay tax if they were liable.

A worked example: goods out for job work

Suppose a furniture maker sent 500 cut steel sheets to a job worker for powder coating on 25 June 2017, under the old excise rules. GST started on 1 July 2017.

  1. Declare the goods Both the manufacturer and the job worker declared the goods held with the job worker in the transition forms.
  2. Return within six months The coated sheets came back on 10 October 2017, well within six months, so no tax was payable on their return.
  3. If they had come back late Had they not come back within six months (or the extended period), the credit taken on those inputs could have been recovered.

Today’s GST job work rules work in a similar way, but with longer time limits: one year for inputs and three years for capital goods such as moulds and dies.

Summary table

SituationSectionTime limitOutcome
Goods out for job work1416 months (+2)No tax on return in time
Goods returned by customer142(1)6 monthsRefund of old duty
Price revision142(2)30 daysSupplementary invoice or credit note
Pending refunds and appeals142(3)–(8)As per old lawDecided under old law
Long-term contracts142(10)Supplies after GSTTaxed under GST
Goods on approval142(12)6 monthsNo tax if returned in time

The 2017 transition windows are closed. This guide is for understanding old records, assessments and disputes, and for lessons that still apply when tax rules change.

Why these rules still matter

Many of these situations were later checked in assessments, and some led to disputes. The same ideas also return whenever tax rules change: what to do with goods out for job work, returns of goods sold before the change, and contracts that span the change date. Today’s job work rules, for example, still use time limits of one year for inputs and three years for capital goods. See our GST manufacturing guide.

This guide explains GST rules in simple words and reflects the law as we understand it on 28 October 2026. Rules, rates and dates change, so please confirm with your CA or the official notifications before acting on it.

FAQ

Questions about special cases, answered.

Short answers to the questions we hear most about this topic.

Need help with GST in your software?

Our team can show you how Milaan ERP handles this in practice.

What did Section 141 cover?

Goods sent for job work under the old law before GST and returned after GST. No tax was payable if they came back within six months, extendable by two.

What happened to goods returned after GST began?

Duty-paid goods sold up to six months before GST and returned within six months after could get a refund of the old duty, if identifiable.

How were price revisions handled?

A supplementary invoice, debit note or credit note had to be issued within 30 days of the revision, and was treated as issued under GST.

Were old refund claims lost?

No. They were decided under the old law and paid in cash where due.

How were long-term contracts taxed?

Supplies made on or after 1 July 2017 under earlier contracts were taxed under GST.

Do these rules apply today?

The transition windows are closed, but the provisions still matter for old assessments and disputes, and similar ideas apply when tax rules change.

Job work and returns, handled the right way today

Milaan ERP tracks job work challans, returns and credit notes as you work. Try it free for 14 days.